Table 4.11

By ctacker (****)

Date 09-22-2007 23:45 Edited 09-23-2007 00:03

Table 4.11 fillet option 1 refers you to fig 4.36 which in my book is a butt joint for ESW & EGW welding operator qual. how can you get a fillet weld on that profile?
Also Tests on ESW & EGW (3) show a groove with fig. 4.35. shouldnt that be fig. 4.36

Edit. just found fig 4.37 showing option 1. looks like aws needs to have an inspector checking the editor!
edit #2. the plug weld refers you to fig. 4.37 SB 4.38
edit #3. fillet option 2 refers you to fig. 4.32 SB 4.33 maybe I been looking at numbers too long today! and maybe Ross can get me 1/365 of the salary an editor makes!

By strat

Date 09-23-2007 01:12

ctacker , im not trying to be smart or anything but what code book are you looking in , aws d1.1 but what year

By ctacker (****)

Date 09-23-2007 01:43

'06

Attachment: Picture.jpg (0B)

By strat

Date 09-23-2007 01:55

hey ctacker , i also have 06 and in table 4.11 fillet option 1 refers to Fig.4.37 , wonder whats up with that.

By ctacker (****)

Date 09-23-2007 02:09

dont think i'm mistaken,my previous post shows it

By MBSims

Date 09-23-2007 04:06

I believe there was an errata issued for the figure numbers referenced in the tables. See the description on the first page for pages 145-149.

http://files.aws.org/technical/d1/errata_d1-1-2006.pdf

By ctacker (****)

Date 09-23-2007 04:12

thanks, I looked at bookstore and searched for errata and got nothing!

By MBSims

Date 09-23-2007 15:28

No problem. I remembered it from marking up my copy with all the corrections a couple of months ago. I usually do that then put a copy of the errata in the front of the book.

By HgTX

Date 09-26-2007 15:54

Yeah, for some reason they don't file it with the publications; you have to go to "services", then "technical standards", and then if you happen to glance at the upper right corner, there's the link.

Anyone from AWS listening? You should have a link to the errata on the bookstore page--preferably a link from the particular publication page to the errata for that publication.

Hg