Sounds like it. In order to stay in the pre-qual parameters, you/ they must stay within the settings that the manufacturer of the wire recommends. If you go outside of them you will have to qualify the procedure, so it's easier to stay within them. This of course is taking into consideration that there is a range of +/- per the table in the code (I assume D1.1). I can't remember the table #, I'm at home.
Are you welding machines calibrated? that could be why some of the values are all over the place as well.
We don't use Chinese wire, but keep an eye on anything that comes from over there, especially HSS tubes.
Chris