Not logged inAmerican Welding Society Forum
Forum AWS Website Help Search Login
Up Topic Welding Industry / Technical Discussions / Maintenance Welding/PWHT of In-service caustic Piping
- - By JoeWelder (*) Date 05-21-2008 18:23
There is some confusion at our site as to whether or not welding and successive PWHT can be completed on piping that has been in Caustic service (that originally was PWHT for caustic service).  There is a site specific policy that says "No" as there is a chance of cracking by both the welding process and the PWHT (apparenlty there is some history to this, but nothing documented, nor does anyone remember the incident that would have led to such a policy).  Our maintenance welders (who are in constant rotation) say that this maintence welding (ie. flange installation) is performed at other sites without issue.  I personnaly have no experience to side eitherway.

Can anyone help solve the debate?  Is there a concern for cracking? or can the welding/PWHT be completed with proper clean-out/prep conditions?

Please help...thanks,

Joe Welder.
Parent - By G.S.Crisi (****) Date 05-21-2008 20:21
Let me see if I've understood exactly your problem.
There's a piping at your plant for caustic service. In chemistry, by caustic service it's meant caustic soda (sodium hydroxide) at a minimum concentration of 5%. Other strong alkalyne substances also fall into this classification, such as caustic potash, concentrated sodium carbonate etc. 
Concentrated ammonia, on the other hand, is not considered a caustic substance because ammonia is a weak alkaly.
The piping has been put out of service to weld a new flange on it, and you're worried as to whether it can be welded because there is a chance of cracking due to the caustic service the piping has been subjected to.
Am I right up to this point?
If so, let's put our horse sense to work.
Why should cracking occur? Because it's still wet with the caustic substance, is the logical answer.
If we get rid of the caustic substance could we be able to make the weld? I would say so.
How can we get rid of the caustic substance? By washing the piping inside surface with plenty of water. The more water, the better.
How will we know that the caustic substance has been washed away? By testing the outflowing water with phenolphtaleine. Take a sample of water from time to time and test it with a few drops of phenolphtaleine. If it gets red, the washing is not complete. When it doesn't get red any more, the washing is complete and there's no caustic in contact with the pipe material.
At this point, in my opinion, the welding may be carried out.
Of course, you'll run into another problem: how to dispose the washing water containing caustic substance in an "environment friendly" manner. You should make some further research (this is the site of the AWS, not the EPA's).
Giovanni S. Crisi
Sao Paulo - Brazil         

  
Up Topic Welding Industry / Technical Discussions / Maintenance Welding/PWHT of In-service caustic Piping

Powered by mwForum 2.29.2 © 1999-2013 Markus Wichitill