I'll probably get flamed pretty good for this but some things can't be ignored.
1) Why don't you try clicking your little mouse thing on Joseph P. Kane's blue name at the top to go to his profile and see what it says about him.
2) Go back to a thread in 'Inspections' titled "Joseph Kane in Inspection Trends", an article recently sent out to AWS/CWI's on things going on in the inspection arena.
3) Go the the article, which can be found here in the AWS forum and read what it has to say about our Joseph Kane.
4) Just because you work for a fly by night outfit that doesn't want it's people to take the time to do things right does not mean that you should take lightly the constructive comments of those who have the responsibility of looking at the work for conformance to all appropriate codes involved. They/we (and you as welders) also have the job of helping to prevent problems before they occur.
5) Even if some of the application doesn't apply directly to you doesn't mean it wasn't well intentioned and wouldn't be worth looking into as far as some changes to make your very nice looking product even more attractive to a wider field of customers who do have to be careful of things that don't concern you.
6) If requested, my powder coaters can easily 'mask' the tip to leave the coating off in the first place. Would make a more attractive finished product that didn't need modification.
Why is it we have the 'shoot all who represent a slightly different viewpoint' mentality on this site lately? I find the variety of experience, knowledge, and application very informative and interesting.
And in this particular case, I don't really see the problem. Yes, I am a certified welder, shop owner, inspector. It doesn't take that long to make sure the connections are right and will not cause a problem. All it takes is one out of ten to make it worth the time plus some. It is not only time you are ultimately saving, it is a superior quality of product that doesn't need extra steps by inspectors to make sure the arc strike did not cause damage that renders the whole part unusable. If you have to totally replace it how much do you lose? Maybe this is not a consideration on your jobs, but, I can affirm very dogmatically that it is on many jobs.
Okay, I'm done. Just my usual two tin pennies worth. Flame away.
Have a Great Day, Brent