Bill:
Have run into this before as a building inspector. (Sounds like embeds to me.) The D1.4 has always supersceded the PCI requirement. Please all forum users note I can only speak from what I have experienced. The actual throat dimension requirement would be determined by the direction of loading.
I get lot's of weird projects that exceed the requirements just noted. It depends if there's uplift, if it's part of a seismic system, etc. Only the engineer who did your design could truly answer your particular question regarding your particular application.
This is where one of those crying dolls would be very appropriate. The ironworkers will dispense bodily fluids of "what the norm" is.
I would have cut a check for a boat load of them crying welder doll's. Too bad it was another cyber hoax.