MMPW:
Your "cup and saucer" test will qualify you in accordance with AMS-STD-1595-03 as follows:
1.) Min. Thickness = 0.018" [0.067t] (5.3.1)
2.) Max. Thickness = 0.108" [4t] (5.3.1)
3.) Tube Dia. = 1.5" and greater (5.5.1.2)
D17.1 cross reference:
1.) 4.3.3.1(1, 2)
2.) 4.3.3.1(1, 2)
3.) 4.3.3.1(3)
Good Luck.