Qualify the procedure with the base metals being joined in production and then qualify the welders.
My preference is to qualify the welders with the same materials and filler metals as to be used on the project. If this is a job that will be welded using SMAW, I strongly suggest you insist on each welder passing the T-Fillet break test. It is very difficult to get the fillet to fuse to the root.
I know what the code requires and permits, but you have to consider what is in the best interest of your employer. There are lessons to be learned when qualifying the procedure and the welders. This is one of those cases where a conservative approach will serve you well.
Best regards - Al