I have a couple other problems. My qualified ranges for thicknesses were listed wrong. I mis-read two clauses:
Table 4.2 (10) D is for "other than" arc spot listing wps qual ranges
Table 4.2 (10) a is for arc spot.
And clause 4.7.2 (3a)i is for square groove, 4.7.2 (1) is for arc spot
listing welder qual ranges
Man, I can't read for squat somedays....I read the wrong ranges many, many times over thinking I had it all straight before typing it onto the documents. Welp, humble pie tastes awful that is for sure. For some reason I saw these ranges in the new 2018 code thinking they come around and gave us more room when qualifying WPS and Welders. Duh....I was incorrect they haven't changed from 10 years ago in the 2008 version.