The welds seen in the photos would be discouraged for today's critical applications. Due to the very wide weave, heat input for the welds shown would be quite high and for today's high strength steels could cause loss of some necessary properties, e.g. CVN's, CTOD's, etc. For SMAW a weave of 2X to 3X the core wire diameter would be in the range of recommended practice. Also, the apparent several inch long "arc strike" on the last photo would be something to be avoided.